Shopping Cart
Your Cart is Empty
There was an error with PayPalClick here to try again
CelebrateThank you for your business!You should be receiving an order confirmation from Paypal shortly.Exit Shopping Cart

Butter Sugar Bake

Thank you for stopping by! 

- Myrna 

Custom cookies are priced by the dozen, with exception for

Holiday cookies ( Easter, Christmas, Fall, etc.).

     Basics  $40/ Dozen

     1-3 color options

     3 designs per dozen

     Cookies measure  between 3 - 4.5 inches. 

     Minimum of 2 dozen per custom order.


Basics Plus  $44/ Dozen

1-5 color options

Up to 4 Designs per dozen

Elaborate and basic piping combination, characters, or lettering.

Cookies measure between 3 and 4.5 inches.

Minimum of 2 dozen per custom order.

     Elaborate   $48/Dozen

     1-5 color options (hand-painted colors included)

     Up to 6 designs per dozen

     Minimal to moderate piping, metallics and/ or hand painted           images.

     Cookies measure 3 to 4.5 inches.

     Minimum of 2 dozen per custom order

Elaborate Plus   $52/Dozen

1 - 8 colors

Up to 8 designs per dozen

Elaborate piping and details, metallics (sprayed-on and/or applied with brush), hand-painted designs, logos, 

detailed characters, lettering, etc.

Cookies measure between 3 to 4.5 inches.

Minimum of 2 dozen per custom order 

Mini Cookies  $15/Dozen

1 to 6 color options

1 to 6 Designs

Cookies measure between 1.5 - 2 inches. 

These are popular to give as gifts. Not all cookie cutters are available in mini size.

Minimum of 2 dozen per custom order.


Single Swirl Frosting

$30 per dozen

Double Swirl Frosting

$35 per dozen

Payments,  Deposits, Cancellations, Refunds,  Important Details

  • ~Payment Due: A 50% deposit is required at the time order is placed; deposit secures availability for your special event!  YAY! Remaining fee is due 48 hours prior to Pick-up date. A friendly reminder will be sent to you.

  • ~Refunds: Deposit refunds can only be made if the order is cancelled 2 weeks prior to Pick-up date. If order is cancelled less than 2 weeks from Pick-up date, deposit is not refundable. In the case of illness or family emergency, where Butter Sugar Bake must cancel an order, a full refund will be provided.

  • ~Covid Care: We know we cannot always control with whom we come in contact; if necessary, we will freeze your cookies up to 2 weeks so you can stay home and rest.   

  • ~Cottage Food Law in Texas:  Each individually bagged and heat-sealed cookie has a (state-law required) label stating that our products are made in my home kitchen, which is not subject to a state inspection. Bagging your Amazing cookies prevents breakage and maintains them fresh for up to two weeks. Hurray! If you prefer not to have said (state-law required) label, please let us know and your cookies will not be individually bagged. Please keep in mind - cookies not bagged run the risk of breaking. Oh, no!! They will still be Yummy! 

  • ~Payment Submission: Once you have submitted payment (deposit or full payment) you agree to this Terms...  we Thank You!
  • ~Forms of Payment: We take checks when mailed 2 weeks in advance, payable to Butter Sugar Bake, LLC;                   Cash (if you are willing to drive) or with PayPal at [email protected], PayPal fee applies.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Do you ship your products?

     Sadly, no I do not ship my products. Per Texas Law, Legal Home Bakeries in Texas are not allowed to ship their products. 


2. Do you make or use designs with Licensed Characters? 

    I do not make any designs that hold a Copyright; such as TV Shows or movie characters, etc. That is copyright infringement.

3. Is there a minimum for orders?

    Yes, a minimum is required. See below.

  • Cookies Minimum - 1 dozen (except Mini size)
  • Cupcakes Minimum - 1 dozen Regular or Jumbo (minimum of $30)
  • Holiday Minimum (Easter, Thanksgiving, Christmas, etc.) - 1 dozen Cookies , 1 dozen Cupcakes

4. What flavor are the cookies?

    All cookies are flavored with vanilla extract.  

Thank you for visiting our site! We look forward to hearing from you!

Myrna Barber

Butter Sugar Bake, LLC

Serving the Greater Houston area

Iced Sugar Cookies, Cupcakes, Cakes, and Seasonal Treats:

Product contains the following allergens:

Eggs, Nuts, Soy, Peanuts, Milk, Wheat

This food is made in a home kitchen and

is not inspected by the Department of State Health Services

or a local health department.

Contact Us

Hello! I am ready to make amazing cookies or cupcakes for your celebration.

Let's get these ideas started!

 All emails are answered within 24 hours. Thank you for stopping by!

This site uses Google reCAPTCHA technology to fight spam. Your use of reCAPTCHA is subject to Google's Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

Thank you! Your message was sent successfully.